top of page

Are Cruise Shore Excursions Worth It? How to Decide Before You Book

Writer: Linda Jones
Linda Jones
Nov 8
11 min read

Shore days can be the best part of a cruise, and a lot of advice about them is about logistics: how far the port is, what it costs, how much time you have. Those things matter, but they are the second question. The first one is what you actually want to experience when you get there.


I have been cruising a long time on many lines, and here is how I think about this decision.


I used to believe booking through the ship was the only way to go, until a private catamaran day changed my mind, and a return trip to the same port changed it again.


So, are cruise shore excursions worth it? If there is something you really want to do in a port, usually yes. If you would be just as happy wandering, shopping and finding lunch on your own, often no. Below is how I would work through it, how to choose between a ship excursion and a third-party tour, and the mistakes I would help you avoid.





Key Takeaways


  • Start with what you want to experience, not how far the port is. If there is something you really want to do, like scuba diving, a helicopter flight or a wildlife tour, it is usually worth booking even when the port is easy to explore on foot.

  • A walkable port is a reason to skip an excursion only when what you want to do is also within easy reach on your own.

  • In my experience, excursions offered through the ship are very often excellent, and on Princess they are usually really good.

  • Ship excursions can cost more, but there are third-party options priced similarly and some that are cheaper. Third-party companies often have more selection and more private options.

  • If you book third-party, choose a company with plenty of reviews, such as Project Expedition or Shore Excursions Group. Many now include a return-to-ship guarantee, which is not the same as the ship waiting, so read what it covers.

  • Cancellation deadlines and refund rules vary by cruise line and by operator. Read them before you prepay.

  • Book your must-do excursion early and leave the rest of your port days flexible.


Start with what you want to experience


Before you look at prices or distance, ask yourself one question about each port: what would make this day great for me? For some people that is a long lunch and a walk around town. For others it is scuba diving, a helicopter flight over a glacier, a small-boat wildlife tour or a cooking class. Those are very different days, and they call for different decisions.


That is why I do not like blanket rules like skip the excursion if the port is walkable. A port can be easy to explore on foot and still not offer the thing you would love to do. If you really want to go scuba diving, the fact that the town is walkable does not change that. If what you want is to wander, shop and eat, you may not need an excursion at all.


When an excursion is usually the right call


  • There is something specific you really want to do. This is the biggest reason. If it is an experience you would regret missing, book it.

  • The activity needs a guide, gear or a boat. Snorkeling, scuba diving, ziplining, wildlife tours and glacier trips are good examples.

  • The main attraction is far from the port. If it is a long drive or a ferry ride away, an excursion handles the transport and the timing for you.

  • You only have a few hours in port. A well-planned tour can cover the highlights without you managing the clock.

  • A new country or language makes you nervous. Having someone else handle navigation can make a first port day much calmer.

  • Mobility or stamina is a factor. Accessible vehicles and a steady pace can matter more than the savings.


In my experience, the excursions offered through the ship are very often excellent. On Princess, for example, most of them are really good. If there is one you are excited about, that is usually a good use of your money. Quality still varies by port and by tour, so read the description closely before you book.


When it is something you really want to do, I think the premium for a ship excursion is worth it. When you book through the ship, the cruise line has put its name behind the tour, and in my experience the cruise line is more invested in what its guests go on than a third-party company is. That is my opinion rather than a guarantee, and a well-reviewed third-party company can be excellent too.


When I would skip an excursion


  • What you want to do is right there on foot. If the thing you want to see or do is within easy reach of the dock, you may not need a tour to do it.

  • You would rather have a free, unplanned day. Not every port needs a plan. A day to wander, shop or sit at a cafe can be just as good as a big excursion. In fact, I encourage you to keep at least one port excursion free so you have the freedom to be spontaneous or not even leave the ship if you prefer.

  • The tour is mostly time on a bus. Check how long you will actually spend at each stop, not just the total length of the tour.

  • It is a repeat visit. If you already know what you want to see, you may not need a guide.

  • It is mainly a beach day. In many ports you can reach a beach on your own for far less.


Once you know what you want: ship excursion or third-party?


Neither option is automatically better. Ship excursions can cost more, but there are third-party options priced similarly and some that are cheaper. Third-party companies often have more selection and more private options. Here is how they usually compare, although the details vary by cruise line, port and company:



Ship excursion

Third-party tour

Price

Often higher, since the cruise line adds its cut

Often similar, and some are cheaper; private and small-group tours can cost more

Selection

A good range, and in my experience often excellent

Often more selection and more private options

If you run late

The ship generally waits for ship-sponsored tours that run late

The ship will not wait, but many reputable companies now include a return-to-ship guarantee; read exactly what it covers

Cancellation

Handled through the cruise line, with deadlines that vary by line

Set by the operator and may differ, so read the terms

Group size

Often large groups and motorcoaches

Often smaller, and private tours are possible

Vetting

Reviewed and endorsed by the cruise line

You choose the company, so pick one with plenty of reviews

If the port changes

Typically adjusted or refunded by the cruise line

Depends on the operator's terms


Ship excursions are the simplest choice: one booking, the ship waits if the tour runs late, and the cruise line handles changes. Third-party tours can give you more choice and more private options, often at a similar or lower price, as long as you pick a company carefully.


Choosing a third-party company


If you book third-party, choose a company with plenty of reviews and a track record. Two I would point you to are Project Expedition and Shore Excursions Group.


Many third-party companies now include a return-to-ship guarantee. Project Expedition, for example, says that if a tour runs late and you miss departure, it covers the logistics and costs to get you to the next port, and Shore Excursions Group advertises a similar guarantee. That is not the same as the ship waiting for you, and the terms differ by company, so read what is covered and any conditions before you book.


What I used to think vs. what I think now


The common advice falls into two camps: always book through the ship so you never miss the boat, or always book on your own because ship tours are overpriced. Both are true some of the time. The question that settles most of it is what you want to experience.

boats floating in the ocean in front of a rocky island

I used to think booking through the cruise line was the best, and only, option. Then I tried a third-party excursion: a private catamaran tour with homemade food, an open bar and a guide who took us to all the best spots. It was phenomenal. Ship excursions often have few private options, so I decided third-party was the way to go.


Years later, I sailed to the same port and went looking for that same tour. The private options now cost quite a bit more, and the selection is hit or miss: more choices in some ports, fewer in others.


So here is what I believe now. Every port is different, and the options change. Start with what you want to experience, then compare what the cruise line offers with what third-party companies offer: reviews, price, how private it is.


The practical takeaway is to decide port by port, starting with what you want out of the day.


How to decide for each port


  1. Ask what you want to experience in this port. Is there something you would really regret missing?

  2. Check whether you can do it easily on your own, on foot, by taxi or by public transport.

  3. If it needs a guide, gear, a boat or a long trip, compare the ship excursion with third-party options for your whole group, including tips and any gear rentals.

  4. Check the timing. When is all-aboard, and how much buffer does the return time leave you?

  5. Read the cancellation terms before you prepay, and write down the deadline.


Shore excursion mistakes to avoid


  • Skipping the thing you really want to do. Saving money, or deciding the port is walkable, is not a good reason to pass on an experience you would love, especially bucket list items such as dog sledding in Alaska.

  • Booking every port day before you sail. Book the one or two must-dos and keep the rest flexible.

  • Cutting the return too close. If a tour gets you back near all-aboard time, pick a different one.

  • Booking with a company you have not checked. Choose one with plenty of reviews, and confirm what is included and how its return-to-ship guarantee works.

  • Skipping the cancellation terms. Deadlines vary by line and operator, and some close weeks before sailing.

  • Ignoring the activity level. A moderate walking tour in the heat is very different from a gentle drive.

  • Forgetting that ports can change. Weather and other disruptions can change or cancel a port stop, so know how refunds work before you book.


How and when to book


Many cruise lines let you book excursions online before you sail, and some also sell them on board. Popular and small-group tours can sell out, so if there is one thing you have your heart set on in a port, book it early as long as the cancellation terms are reasonable. Check your cruise line's website for when booking opens for your sailing and what the cancellation deadline is.


Disclosure: some links in this post, including those to Project Expedition and Shore Excursions, may be affiliate links. If you book through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.


Frequently asked questions


Are cruise shore excursions worth it?


It comes down to what you want to experience. If there is something you really want to do in a port, such as scuba diving, a helicopter flight or a wildlife tour, an excursion is usually worth it, even when the port is easy to walk around. If you would be just as happy wandering, shopping and finding lunch on your own, you may not need one. Practical factors still matter: a long distance from the ship, the need for a guide or gear, and limited time in port all point toward booking. Look at the port on a map, then decide what you want your day to be.


Are ship excursions more expensive than booking on your own?


Often, yes. Ship-sponsored tours usually cost more than the same tour booked directly, because the cruise line adds its margin for handling the booking and backing it up. That said, some third-party options are priced similarly and some are cheaper, while private and small-group tours can cost more. Prices vary widely by port and cruise line, so compare the same itinerary side by side, including what is included, before you decide.


Will the ship wait for me if I am late?


Ships generally wait for guests on ship-sponsored excursions that run late, because the cruise line knows where those guests are. If you book a third-party tour or explore on your own, the ship will not wait. Many reputable third-party companies now include a return-to-ship guarantee that helps get you to the next port if you miss departure, but the terms vary, so read what it covers. Either way, treat the all-aboard time as a firm deadline and plan to be back well before it.


Can you cancel a shore excursion on a cruise?


Usually, but the deadlines and refund rules vary by cruise line and by excursion type. Princess, for example, asks you to cancel before the closing time printed on your excursion ticket, and for excursions that include things like flights, hotels or private vehicles, that closing time can be 30 days before sailing. Third-party operators set their own terms, so read them before you prepay and write down the deadline. Check your cruise line's current policy, because it can change.


How far in advance should I book shore excursions?


Booking windows vary by cruise line, but many let you book excursions online months before you sail, and popular or small-group tours can sell out. If there is one excursion that is the reason you are going to a port, I would book it as early as your line allows, as long as the cancellation terms are reasonable. For everything else, it is fine to wait and see how the trip is shaping up. Check your cruise line's website for when booking opens for your sailing rather than relying on a general rule.


Do I need to book an excursion at all?


No. In many ports you can walk off the ship and explore on your own, and an unplanned day can be a great one. But if there is something you really want to do, I would book it, even in a walkable port, unless you can easily do it on your own. You may also want an excursion, or at least a reliable ride, when the attractions are far from the pier, when you want a specific activity, or when mobility makes independent transport harder. Ask yourself what you want to experience, then decide how much you want to manage yourself.


Are shore excursions included in the cruise fare?


On most mainstream cruise lines, excursions cost extra and are not included in your cruise fare. Some premium, luxury and expedition-style lines include certain excursions, and some promotions add an excursion credit. What is included varies by line, cabin category and promotion, so check your booking details and ask your travel advisor before assuming anything is covered. Even when an excursion is included, there may be limits on how many you can take or which ones you can choose.


How much time should I leave to get back to the ship?


Plan to be back well before the all-aboard time in your daily schedule, which is usually set ahead of the ship's actual departure. For third-party tours, I would build in a generous cushion beyond what the operator promises, since traffic, ferries, tenders and long lines at the pier can all add time. A buffer of an hour or more is a sensible starting point for a day away from the port, and more if you are going far or relying on a single ride back. If a tour's return time cuts it close, I would pick a different one.


What is the difference between a ship excursion and a third-party tour?


A ship excursion is a tour sold or endorsed by your cruise line. You book it through the line, and if it runs late the ship typically waits. A third-party tour is booked directly with a local operator or through a company that sells excursions from many operators. These often offer more selection and more private options, and the price can be similar or lower. You are responsible for choosing a reputable company with good reviews, understanding the cancellation terms and getting back to the ship on time. Neither is automatically better.


What happens to my excursion if the cruise line changes or skips the port?


Itineraries can change because of weather, strikes, safety concerns or port closures. For ship excursions, the cruise line typically adjusts the plan or refunds cancelled excursions, though the details are up to the line. For third-party tours, it depends on the company's cancellation policy, so check what happens if the ship skips the port before you prepay. Travel insurance coverage varies too, and you can read more in my guide to cruise travel insurance.


Want help planning your cruise?


If you would like help deciding which ports are worth an excursion and which are not, I help travelers plan their cruises.



Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

Ready to start your journey?

Let us craft the perfect travel experience tailored to your unique tastes and preferences. Your next adventure awaits.

bottom of page